Comparison Shopping
Jayson Werth is on the verge of winning a World Series. Mark Teahen is on the verge of getting traded. That’s about the only difference between the two players. Oh, and Teahen plays two more defensive positions at a high level.
So, how do the Phillies win it all with Werth, and the Royals are playing the blame game with Teahen? The answer is Ryan Howard. And Jimmy Rollins. And in a round about way, David Ortiz.
How so?
Statiscally speaking, Mark Teahen and Jayson Werth are nearly exact copies of one another through their first 500 career games. (Werth is at 460 career, Tea is at 532) Werth has more homeruns, Tea more Doubles and triples. In another comparison I discovered that the first 2 full seasons of Alex Gordon and J.D. Drew were distinctly similar. So, the question becomes, why are the Royals not better? They have the clones of Jayson Werth and J.D. Drew, plus the uniquely talented David Dejesus. Why not more runs, why not a better offense?
No boppers. No Ryan Howard, No David Ortiz. No MVP shortstop scoring all those runs. It all comes back to talent, and the Royals do not have enough. They are missing one key element from their offensive lineup. That’s a phrase that can be applied to both teams at the Truman Sports Complex. In Football no team can contend without a top-shelf quarterback. Even if he doesn’t throw for 300 a game, a quarterback drives the rest of the offense and controls what the defense must do to prepare for the rest of the team on each play. A true slugger, an offensive force, drives the batting order and effects what pitches are thrown to every other batter in the order. He impacts the game in a way no other non-pitcher does. Look at what Manny Ramirez did to the Dodger lineup this past fall. Or the effect Albert Pujols had on the otherwise pedestrian Cardinal Lineup.
The Royals are considering trading Teahen for a similar player, maybe 2. They have discussed trading a power arm from the minor leagues for the next Crash Davis, a minor league homerun guy. Why? Why get rid of pieces of the puzzle when you can see where they would fit on a successful team. The Phillies actively pursued Werth because they knew he would fit a role on a successful team. Of course they also had Pat Burrell, Jimmy Rollins and Ryan Howard already in their lineup.
So who is the guy? Who will be the man for the Royals? Billy Butler? Mike Moustakas? I don’t know, but I know they need to find him soon.
